Smela

2017 2018 2019 2020 2021

Transparency

Ranked

31.40

Overall score

Accountability

Ranked

Overall score

Transparency and Accountability

Transparency

Accountability

Information on the work of local government

5.60/-

Access and participation

5.70/-

Procurement

1.00/-

Housing policy

1.50/-

Budget process

2.50/-

Financial and material assistance, grants

1.00/-

Social services

0.00/-

HR matters

1.00/-

Anti-corruption policy and professional ethics

3.50/-

Land use and constuaction policy

1.50/-

Municipal enterprises

0.90/-

Municipal property

3.00/-

Education

0.50/-

Investment and economic development

3.70/-

Transparency

Accountability

Want to join your city's accountability assessment? The first step is to register on the Transparent Cities online platform.

The pilot Accountability Rating will cover 50 cities of Ukraine, with a list of all participating cities you can find in the menu tab "Accountability Rating of 50 cities". If your city is included in the Rating - go to the city map for the 2020 evaluation. Next - leave a detailed response on the implementation of an indicator in 14 areas of local government. To do this, go to the list of areas, click on the desired area, select the indicator from the drop-down list and comment on it. Each indicator contains detailed instructions to help you score.

You can also leave a general review, or view all reviews on the state of accountability of the city. To do this, use the appropriate buttons on the right.

View reviews Leave feedback

Transparency Accountability

Overall score

Ranked

Dynamics compared to the previous year

Detailed rating